Segmentation based on our competitive advantages? Posted by Tomi Heikkinen , Friday, September 11, 2009 at 14:19, in Labels: chris fill, competitive advantage, kelly page, paul baines, segmentation, targeting, tomi heikkinen

Thanks to the upcoming Cranfield Experience(tm), I've been pre-reading Marketing by Paul Baines, Chris Fill and Kelly Page (2008). I'll possibly review the book later in depth, but many points have come to mind while reading their comprehensive, massive, but excellent textbook, and one in particular stirred some thinking.

The authors discuss the basics of segmentation and targeting. They go through both consumer and business market aspects of S&T, and while describing the business side of things, they mention some limitations of market segmentation. A particularly interesting point was that there is insufficient consideration how market segmentation is linked to competitive advantage. Moreover, market segmentation has not tended to stress the need to segment on the basis of differentiating the offering from competitors.

Why is this interesting? First we might consider what is competitive advantage. In rough layman's terms it means doing something critical to the customer so much better than the competitor OR having something critical to the customer that the competition has not. A sustainable competitive advantage furthermore is an edge that cannot be easily swayed from the supplier. However the competitive advantage is possibly two-fold: on one side, it's critical to the supplier because it enables it to differentiate from the competition. But on the other side, it might be critical to the customer - the supplier might have been selected because of the competitive advantage, ergo the offering should be vital to the customer's business. It is obvious not all businesses can have competitive advantages that are so remarkable. But shouldn't every business strive to develop advantages that become immensely important parts of the core businesses of their customers? Isn't it every CEO's dream?

Back to segmentation and targeting. A starting business, or even an established firm with a new business, should among other things consider their targeting according to their competitive advantages and their strengths. In other words, be both competition and customer-oriented. Key questions might be: What are our sustainable competitive advantages? For whom are we the most potent suppliers? Which advantage is most profitable? Who benefits most of our advantages, and are they profitable too? What kind of demands are we best suited to fulfill? Who are the customers to whom we could become a lifeline? A bit of blue ocean thinking too never hurts.

Maybe a well thought-out toolbox or a framework/mindset is in order? And maybe I just came up with a thesis project for myself?